@2024 Afarand., IRAN
ISSN: 2008-2630 Iranian Journal of War & Public Health 2019;11(1):49-60
ISSN: 2008-2630 Iranian Journal of War & Public Health 2019;11(1):49-60
Designing the Model of Factors Affecting the Physical and Psychological Damage of Iranian Captives in Iraqi Camps and Harm Reduction Strategies
ARTICLE INFO
Article Type
Qualitative StudyAuthors
Nabavichashmi S.R. (1)Feiz D. (1*)
Rastgar A.A. ()
(1) Business Administration Department, Economics & Management Faculty, University of Semnan, Semnan, Iran
Correspondence
Address: Economics & Management Faculty, University of Semnan, 5 Kilometer of Damghan Road, Semnan, Iran. Postal Code: 3513119111Phone: +98 (23) 33339981
Fax: +98 (23) 33339981
feiz1353@semnan.ac.ir
Article History
Received: February 26, 2018Accepted: October 9, 2018
ePublished: March 16, 2019
BRIEF TEXT
In the Iran-Iraq war, many Iranian soldiers were captured by the Iraqi army. They faced several problems in the camps, of which physical and mental health was one of the important risks.
... [1-4]. Mousavi et al. determined and prioritized the health problems of the prisoners of war. The most important health problems of the prisoners of war were post-traumatic depression, dental caries, depression, anxiety and bone and joint diseases [5]. ... [6-10]. Kiani et al. research showed that the optimal use of sports activities during leisure time can improve the physical and mental health and improve the social relationships of the veterans [11]. In addition to sports and sports activities for reducing physical and mental disorders, cultural-artistic activities and programs can also be effective in reducing these injuries. Narimani in a research on the stressor experiences of captivity and the ways of coping with it said that cultural programs, such as praying, hymn, sports programs and various types of hobbies were methods to deal with a variety of stresses and diseases in the camps [12]. ... [13].
The aim of this study was to design a model of factors affecting the physical and psychological damages of Iranian prisoners of war and the methods to prevent and treat them in Iraqi camps.
This research is a descriptive-survey study.
This study was conducted on prisoners of war in Semnan from the early 2016 to late 2017.
20 prisoners of war who were captured in Iraq, including strategic leaders, directors and those with cultural activists were interviewed, of whom 15 subjects were registered by the Red Cross an 5 subjects were listed as missing in action.
Data was collected through semi-structured interviews and literature review. Data collection continued to reach data saturation. Data was encoded after the collection, then the model was extracted from them. After collecting the initial information through the interviews and references they were recorded in the table for each interview or text, the codes then were selected and numbered (open coding). Coding was accessible, since the researcher had a history of 53 months of captivity, however in order to ensure the right coding at this stage, all the concepts were provided to at least 5 prisoners of war and experts. Accordingly, most of the codes were approved and some were corrected. The suggested titles were collected first through exploratory interviews with experts and prisoners of war for "axial" and "selective" coding and for finding an appropriate code for each category of concepts. Some titles (codes) were usually introduced by the experts for each category of concepts or dimensions, however only an option should be selected as the final option. Multi-voting method was used to find the most suitable option in two stages. The first stage was designed to determine the "component" titles for categorizing concepts (axial coding) and the second stage to indicate "dimensions" for a group of "components". Multi-voting method can be done using the experts, so some of the experts who had the following conditions were selected: 1) The prisoners of war interviewed in the previous stages were informed about this research. 2) The prisoners of war who had at least a Ph.D degree. 3) The prisoners of war who had at least two years of captivity. 4) The prisoners of war who could attend the voting session. Based on the accepted method, the options obtained from the exploratory interview stage were written on the board and the experts were asked to select among the remaining two-thirds options. It continued until an option was selected, based on which the most appropriate option (the selected code) was selected. The validity of the research was approved by interviews, the presence of the researcher in relevant associations, and deep and long interaction with the subject. During the interviews, the researcher's perceptions were monitored while interviewing to overcome the possibility of any misunderstandings from their statements. The expected reliability of this research was well guaranteed and estimated, since the academic experts’ views were used in all stages of the research process.
Table 2 shows some codes extracted from interviews and documents as examples. Some of the characteristics of the prisoners of war are also shown in Table 3. In the resulted model, the factors affecting the physical and mental injuries to the prisoners and the methods of preventing and treating various types of physical and psychological injuries in Iraqi camps were designed and explained according to the mediating role of the strategic leaders of the camp and the Red Cross (Figure 1).Effective factors in physical and psychological injuries to prisoners of war: The most important factors affecting the physical and mental health of the prisoners of war were the poor conditions of prisoners of war’s health and the unfavorable behaviors of Iraqis and some of the Iranian prisoners of war, such as spies, Munafiqun, and those who turned away from the Islamic Republic of Iran as well as some of the underlying factors including repeated life, cultural and ideological differences of prisoners of war, and the lack of prior education about the time of captivity. The role of the Red Cross in reducing physical and mental injuries to prisoners of war: the services of the International Committee of the Red Cross have had a direct or indirect effect on the physical and mental health of the prisoners of war. The role of strategic leaders in reducing physical and mental injuries: Persons such as clerics, teachers, university professors, army commanders, and IRGC officers were saviors of the prisoners of war in crisis situations. Scheduling and decision making in the unstable conditions of the Iraqi camps were considered as two main functions of camp leaders. Cultural-scientific programs: cultural and scientific programs at the camps included religious and national programs, educational classes with various scientific subjects, art classes, and creative and innovation programs. Sports programs: sport programs were one of the most important factors affecting the physical and mental health of prisoners of war in Iraqi camps. They were held in four categories, including sports, martial arts, wrestling, and ball games at the camps. Physical and mental health of prisoners of war: leaders and other experts such as clerics and professors made their best to identify as much as possible the harmful and critical factors that harmed the normal personality of the prisoners of war and also to modify them in order to
According to the literature review and also the researcher studies, so far no specific study has been done on designing factors affecting the physical and psychological injuries of Iranian prisoners of war in Iraqi camps and the strategies for reducing these factors. Studying and explaining the different dimensions of the model and documenting the valuable experiences of 10 years of captivity of Iranian prisoners of war, as an important part of the eight-year Holy Defense is indispensable.
Training aspects of living in camps effective human resources management in camps as well as cultural-sports activities which are a very valuable experience for living in difficult situations via formal and informal training to the targeted groups, especially military personnel is suggested
The limited references about the research subject was one of the limitations of this research.
The prisoners’ cultural-sports activities in the Iraqi camps have positive effects, including increasing the patience of the prisoners, increasing their physical and mental health and their social health level, increasing their freshness, happiness, feeling of trust, concentration and accuracy, and reduction of depression.
The authors are Thankful to the Foundation of Martyrs and Veterans and Payam Azadegan Institute, and the prisoners of war who helped us in this research.
None declared.
The essential coordination was made with the Foundation of Martyrs and Veterans as well as Payam Azadegan Institute and the consent of the participants was obtained.
The present research is extracted from the Ph.D thesis of the first author sponsored by the Foundation of Martyrs and Veterans.
TABLES and CHARTS
Show attach fileCITIATION LINKS
[1]Isa Morad A. Captivity psychology. Kerman: Rooyeh; 2012. pp. 234-44. [Persian]
[2]Karaminia R, Salimi SH, Majdian M. Depression in prisons of war in Iraq-Iran imposed war. J Milit Med. 2007;9(3):179-87. [Persian]
[3]Noorbala AA, Narimani M. The psychology of bondage and psychiatric complications associated with the results of research projects conducted on Iranian Azadegan. Tehran: Shahed University; 1995. [Persian]
[4]Yariari F. A study of neuropsychological manifestations in Azadegan 3rd (one year after return). [Dissertation]. Tehran: Tarbiat Modares University. 1992. [Persian]
[5]Mousavi B, Karbalaei Esmaeili S, Ganjparvar Z, Khaji A, Soroush MR, Amini R. Qualitative study on prisoners of war and health problems. Iran J War Public Health. 2010;2(4):1-7. [Persian]
[6] Kazemi A, Ghaffari Hashjin Z, Keshavarz Shokri A. The study of the collective components of the culture of self-sacrifice and martyrdom in the memoirs of the free defense of the holy defense as a social capital. Islam Revolut Cult Conserv. 2016;6(14):139-73. [Persian]
[7]Gharakhnlu R, Rajabi H, Nikbakht H, Alijani E, Gaeni A. Basic consepts in science of exercise and physical fitness. Tehran. National Olympic Committee of the Islamic Republic of Iran. 2003. [Persian]
[8] Noorbala AA, Narimani M. Study of stressful events after escaping from captivity and its coping methods in azadegan, The First Congress of Social Psychiatry. Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 1994. [Persian]
[9]Mousavi MK. Physical phsycology, an introduction to physical education encyclopeadia ministry of education, research and innovation gread foundation of Farsi language encyclopeaia. 2nd Edition. Tehran: Vezarat Behdsht; 2000. [Persian]
[10]Tofighi A, Nozad J, Babaee S, Dastah S. Effect of aerobic exercise training on general health indices in inactive veterans. Iran J War Public Health. 2013;5(2):40-5. [Persian]
[11]Kiani M, Shirvani T, Ghanbari H, Kiani S. Position on how to spend leisure time sports activities for the veterans and disabled. Iran J War Public Health. 2013;5(2):26-34. [Persian]
[12]Narimani M. Study of stresses during captivity and ways to deal with it in a group of Iranian captivities. The second Symposium on stress. Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 1992. [Persian]
[13]Rahmanian A. achievement of homesickness: Handicraft in captivity. Tehran: payam Azadegan; 2007. [Persian]
[2]Karaminia R, Salimi SH, Majdian M. Depression in prisons of war in Iraq-Iran imposed war. J Milit Med. 2007;9(3):179-87. [Persian]
[3]Noorbala AA, Narimani M. The psychology of bondage and psychiatric complications associated with the results of research projects conducted on Iranian Azadegan. Tehran: Shahed University; 1995. [Persian]
[4]Yariari F. A study of neuropsychological manifestations in Azadegan 3rd (one year after return). [Dissertation]. Tehran: Tarbiat Modares University. 1992. [Persian]
[5]Mousavi B, Karbalaei Esmaeili S, Ganjparvar Z, Khaji A, Soroush MR, Amini R. Qualitative study on prisoners of war and health problems. Iran J War Public Health. 2010;2(4):1-7. [Persian]
[6] Kazemi A, Ghaffari Hashjin Z, Keshavarz Shokri A. The study of the collective components of the culture of self-sacrifice and martyrdom in the memoirs of the free defense of the holy defense as a social capital. Islam Revolut Cult Conserv. 2016;6(14):139-73. [Persian]
[7]Gharakhnlu R, Rajabi H, Nikbakht H, Alijani E, Gaeni A. Basic consepts in science of exercise and physical fitness. Tehran. National Olympic Committee of the Islamic Republic of Iran. 2003. [Persian]
[8] Noorbala AA, Narimani M. Study of stressful events after escaping from captivity and its coping methods in azadegan, The First Congress of Social Psychiatry. Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 1994. [Persian]
[9]Mousavi MK. Physical phsycology, an introduction to physical education encyclopeadia ministry of education, research and innovation gread foundation of Farsi language encyclopeaia. 2nd Edition. Tehran: Vezarat Behdsht; 2000. [Persian]
[10]Tofighi A, Nozad J, Babaee S, Dastah S. Effect of aerobic exercise training on general health indices in inactive veterans. Iran J War Public Health. 2013;5(2):40-5. [Persian]
[11]Kiani M, Shirvani T, Ghanbari H, Kiani S. Position on how to spend leisure time sports activities for the veterans and disabled. Iran J War Public Health. 2013;5(2):26-34. [Persian]
[12]Narimani M. Study of stresses during captivity and ways to deal with it in a group of Iranian captivities. The second Symposium on stress. Iran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran; 1992. [Persian]
[13]Rahmanian A. achievement of homesickness: Handicraft in captivity. Tehran: payam Azadegan; 2007. [Persian]