ARTICLE INFO

Article Type

Descriptive & Survey Study

Authors

Hosseini   S.A. (*)






(*) Geography & Urban Planning Department, Social Sciences Faculty, Rasht Branch, Payam-e-Noor University, Tehran, Iran

Correspondence

Address: Geography & Urban Planning Department, Social Sciences Faculty, Payam-e-Noor University, Mini-City Street, Tehran, Iran. Post Box: 19395-3697
Phone: +98 (13) 33608168
Fax: +98 (13) 33608168
hosieniali@pnu.ac.ir

Article History

Received:  June  28, 2016
Accepted:  December 21, 2016
ePublished:  February 24, 2017

BRIEF TEXT


… [1, 2]. Studies have shown that most of government buildings do not have the appropriate condition for equal access for disabled veterans, which has led to decreased motivation of spatial and social mobility of disabled veterans for active participation in social and economic affairs of the society… [3].

Venter et al. have shown that improved accessibility and mobility of disabled individuals could have an impact on reduction of poverty and disabilities, creation of occupation, and accessibility of disabled individuals to urban services and facilities [4]. … [5-7]. According to Azizi, sustainability of urban public spaces depends on vitality, identity, dynamism, compatibility, diversity, readability, and access to urban spaces [8]. In this regard, Bahmanpour and Salajegheh [9] reported that Laleh Park of Tehran has a moderate condition for disabled individuals. In addition, Bozi et al. [10] used TOPSIS model to evaluate the traffic of Shiraz, Iran. … [11]. In a research by Kamanroodi [12] in Tehran, Iran, it was marked that the centralized structure and dispersed performance of Tehran's urban development management has an inadequate performance for improving the condition of urban spaces for disabled people. … [13].

This research aimed to evaluate the appropriateness level of government buildings in Rasht, Iran, for disabled veterans.

This was a descriptive and survey research.

This study was conducted on 256 government buildings of Rasht in 2016.

In total, 70 buildings were selected through simple random sampling.

Data collection tool was a checklist for evaluation of appropriateness of government buildings. At first, the selected public buildings of Rasht were ranked according to the components of appropriateness using TOPSIS method. In this technique, factors or options are assessed by an individual or a group of decision-makers. In addition, each selected factor must have the minimum distance with the positive ideal factor (the most important) and maximum distance with the negative ideal factor (the least important). In fact, the distance of each factor with positive and negative ideals is evaluated, which will be the criterion for ranking and prioritizing the factors [14]. The TOPSIS method is carried out, as follows: 1. Formation of data matrices based on N alternatives (the selected public buildings of Rasht) and K indicators (requirements and terms of municipal engineering and architecture that is required for design of public buildings to be used by veterans and individuals with physical and motor disabilities). 2. Changing the existing decision matrix to unscaled matrix (the main cause of unscaling the data is the difference between the scale of the data. By performing this process, data were between 0 and 1). 3. Weighting of indicators: analytical hierarchy process was used in Expert Choice Software, and the elements present at each stage of the hierarchy were evaluated from bottom to top, compared to all the elements related to the higher level. At the end, paired comparison matrix was formed (ratio of importance of factors 1–9). After weighting the indicators, the weight of each indicator was multiplied by normalized numbers and a standard data matrix was created. 4. Determining the solution of positive and negative ideals: using the standard data matrix, the highest (A+) and lowest (A–) performances of each indicators were calculated using the equations below: A+ = {(Max Vij|j∈J), (Min Vij–| ∈J^-)|i={1,2,3,…,m})} , J ={1,2,3,...,n) A- = {(Min Vij|j∈J), (Max Vij–| ∈J^-)|i={1,2,3,…,m})} , J– ={1,2,3,...,n) 5. Estimation of the distance of each option from the positive and negative ideals. 6. Determining the relative distance to the best criteria (sum of the number of each line of the tables in the fifth stage was obtained and raised to the exponent of 0.5). 7. Calculation of relative proximity to the ideal solution and ranking of options: relative proximity of –d compared to +d was estimated through the equation below, followed by ranking of options according to the obtained amount between 0 and 1. The more proximity of this amount to 1, the higher the rank. In addition, proximity of this number to zero is indicative of lower rank. 〖cl〗_i^+= (d_i^-)/(〖(d〗_i^++d_i^- )0 ≤〖cl〗_i^+≤ 1 Statistical Analysis: After entering the data into the analysis software, Pearson’s correlation coefficient was used to analyze the relationship between the studied variables.

According to the results, some appropriateness components were observed in some evaluated areas of Rasht. In terms of appropriateness indicator, the highest and lowest ranks were allocated to the municipality and city council buildings of Rasht (Table 1). According to the results of the present research, a significant relationship was observed between the management process of increasing the appropriateness of government buildings and administrative measures for disabled veterans (p=0.0001; r=0.637). In this regard, increased management actions for enhancing the appropriateness of government buildings led to improved executive measures. Moreover, a significant association was found between the cooperation of government organizations and appropriateness of government buildings (p=0.0001; r=0.526). In this respect, increased cooperation of government organizations in the area of appropriateness of buildings improved the overall condition of public buildings. Furthermore, a significant relationship was observed between demographic characteristics of government managers and appropriateness of government buildings (p=0.0001; r=0.56). According to the results, increased age and high work experience, educational level, and social and economic headquarter of managers had a significant relationship with improved appropriateness of government buildings. There was also a significant correlation between preparedness of government buildings and taking measures to increase the level of appropriateness of buildings (p=0.0001; r=0.597). In this regard, increased level of preparedness of government buildings led to elevated number of appropriateness measures.

Urban development theory emphasizes the improvement of level of access and social welfare of citizens. In this regard, despite considerable national and local policy-making and legal measures in the country, the appropriateness planning system has no proper long-, mid- and short-term plans, which are coherent and sustainable with efficient mechanisms for institutional monitoring, controlling, evaluating, and coordinating. The main assumptions of urban management theory are creating proper foundations for all citizens, including disabled veterans and individuals, to have access to public spaces and government buildings, increasing equal opportunities and level of satisfaction of citizens with urban management services, and improving the public spaces by optimal use of limited resources [15]. … [16, 17].

None declared by the authors.

None declared by the authors.

Public and government buildings of Rasht have a moderate condition in terms of access of disabled veterans and individuals and appropriateness measures.

None declared by the authors.

None declared by the authors.

None declared by the authors.

None declared by the authors.

TABLES and CHARTS

Show attach file


CITIATION LINKS

[1]Golkar K. Tailoring swot analytical technique to urban design practice. Soffeh. 2005;15(41):44-64. [Persian]
[2]Shie E, Chehrazi F. Preparing the city for the disabled from the perspective of urban planning. Res Art
[3]Hasanvand S, Ebrahimpour M, Bagheri B, Razmkhah S, Khojaste Ghamari MA. Improving of urban public spaces safety in order to using physical disabled persons. Int J Civ Eng Constr Estate Manag. 2014;1(2):47-56.
[4]Riddell R, Weedon E. Disabled students in higher education: Discourses of disability and the negotiation of identity. Int J Educ Res. 2014;63:38-46.
[5]Morrison J, Basnet M, Budhathoki B, Adhikari D, Tumbahangphe K, Manandhar D, et al. Disabled women׳s maternal and newborn health care in rural Nepal: A qualitative study. Midwifery. 2014;30(11):1132-9.
[6]Husain Z, Ahmad NS. Isolation: willingness of disabled person to integrate with its community in the context of relationship after disabled due to accidents. Procedia Soc Behav Sci. 2010;7:274-81.
[7]Şimşek IE, Erel S, Şimşek TT, Uysal SA, Yakut H, Yakut Y, et al. Factors related to the impact of chronically disabled children on their families. Pediatr Neurol. 2014;50(3):255-61.
[8]Azizi MA. Sustainable residential neighborhood: The case study of narmak neighborhood, tehran. 2006;2(27):35-46. [Persian]
[9]Bahmanpour H, Salagheghe B. The quantitative and qualitative urban spaces for the disabled in Tehran from the user perspective. Urban Manag. 2008;6(3):7-18. [Persian]
[10]Khodarahm B, Kiyani A, Afrasiyabi MS. Evaluation of urban traffic and the needs of veterans using the decision making model, Topsis, Case Study: Shiraz. Res Urban Plann. 2010;1(3):103-130. [Persian]
[11]Taghvayi M, Moradi G, Safarabadi A. Evaluation of Isfahan city parks based on the existing standard for disabled access and disabled veterans. 2010;21(2):47-67. [Persian]
[12]Kamanroudi M. Structural pathology of management and urban development: making appropriate tehran spaces for the disabled. Urban Manag. 2009;8(25):99-114. [Persian]
[13]Unknown Authors. Foundation of Martyrs and Veterans Affairs of Gilan Province; 2015. [Persian]
[14]Azar A, Rajabzade A. The decision applied (MADM approach). Tehran: Ghalam Press; 2010. [Persian]
[15]Unknown Authors. Green roofs, a long step in the right of the urban environment and sustainable architecture. Danesh Nama. 2006;143:59-61. [Persian]
[16]Kadir SA, Jamaludin M. Staff assistance as a crucial aspect of accessibility in public buildings. Procedia Soc Behav Sci. 2013;101:140-6.
[17]Kashanijou Kh. Recognition of theoretical approaches to urban public spaces. Hoviat-e-Shahr. 2010;4(6):95-106. [Persian]