@2024 Afarand., IRAN
ISSN: 2538-4384 Geographical Researches 2021;36(2):99-113
ISSN: 2538-4384 Geographical Researches 2021;36(2):99-113
Site Selection of Potential Zones for Wind-Catchers in Hot and Dry Areas of IRAN to Naturally Ventilate the Building
ARTICLE INFO
Article Type
Original ResearchAuthors
Yahyaei M. (1)Mofidi Shemirani SM. (*2)
Ahmadi V. (1)
(*2) Department of Architecture, Fac- ulty of Architecture and Urbanism, Iran University of Science & Technology, Tehran, Iran
(1) Department of Architecture, Faculty of Arts and Architecture, Mashhad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Mashhad, Iran
Correspondence
Article History
Received: September 4, 2020Accepted: October 20, 2020
ePublished: June 16, 2021
BRIEF TEXT
Nowadays, the consequences and limitations of fossil fuels made people more interested in the use of renewable energy. The construction industry is one of the biggest energy consumers making environmental changes leading to global warming.
Many years ago, people used the available natural potentials to use clean energy [Zandieh & Parvarinejad, 2010]. Iran's traditional architecture has an enriched history considering sustainability, art, and culture [Mahdavinejad & Javanroodi, 2012]. The use of wind-catchers in arid regions is one of the most outstanding features of Iranian engineering that is getting forgotten and turning into an ornamental feature [Poorahmadi & Ayataalahi, 2011]. Optimal geo-locating as one of the most important steps in executive projects analyzes each region's potentials in terms of the availability of the proper space and its relation with other land uses nearby to choose the best place for the needed land use [Arab & Farokhzad, 2020]. The main functions of the wind-catchers can be classified into two parts: to inhale fresh air toward the inner parts of the buildings and exhale the warm and polluted air toward the outside [Mahdavinejad & Javanroodi, 2011].
This study aimed to look for the best locations for the wind-catchers establishment in arid regions of Iran (Semnan province as the studied area) to use the wind-catchers efficiently.
This is an empirical study that used field studies to collect data.
The current research is carried out in the Semnan provinces of Iran from 2017 to 2019.
9 indicators were selected according to the opinions of 17 experts in this field.
The hierarchical Analysis Process (AHP) technique and Geographic Information System were used for the analysis. ArcGIS software and Expert Choice software were used in this study, as well.
Determination of the influential parameter in locating the wind-catchers Six indicators of sunny hours, wind, altitude, temperature, relative humidity, and precipitation which are influential in arid regions' wind-catchers locating were determined (Table 2). Climatic and meteorological data for a 20-year period (1999-2019) were collected from synoptic and climatologic stations of Semnan province (Table 3). Then, a pairwise comparison of the indicators was done according to the opinions of the experts (Table 4). Figure 3 shows that the relative humidity indicator with 0.38 has the highest weight which is followed by the wind indicator with 0.243. The lowest weight is for the altitude indicator with 0.154. Afterward, information layers were drawn as a map for each indicator (Figures 4 to 9). The results of the pairwise comparison of Semnan cities are presented in Figure 10. Clearly, Garmsar, Semnan, and Shahrood were the only one achieved the first rank in some of the indicators. However, Mahdishahr was the last rank in terms of four of the indicators. After the determination of the influential indicators in locating the wind-catchers, information layers should be overlaid using a proper method to get the final map (Figure 11). After the overlaying and the analysis of the layers, proper spots for the wind-catchers establishment were detected and the best location can be selected according to the priority of the influential indicators (Figure 12). Finally, according to the scores gain from pairwise comparisons of the indicators and studied areas, Semnan, Garmsar, Aradan, Sorkhe, Damghan, Shahrood, Miami, and Mahdishahr are respectively the highest to the lowest priorities for the establishment of the wind-catchers.
The western parts of Semnan province including Garmsar, Aradan, Sorkhe, and Semnan are potentially proper for the establishment of the wind-catchers. These results are inconsistent with the results of Valian et al. (2020) because they found out that 80% of the province's wind-catchers are located in Semnan city and 10% are located in Garmsar. Mahdishahr is the least proper city for the establishment of the wind-catchers since it is located in higher altitudes with lower average annual temperature. Moreover, more precipitation shows more cloudiness that reduces sunny hours and decreases the region's potential for the establishment of wind-catchers. Ziari & Khodadadi (2013) and Hekmatnia & Ansari (2012) approve these results. The southern parts of the province are not much proper for the wind-catchers because of the dust, lower relative moisture, higher temperature and lower altitude. Mahdavinejad & Javanroodi (2012) also believe that wind-catchers establishment in southern parts of the province is not essential and logical.
There is no suggestion reported.
There is no limitation reported.
Geo-locating is of great importance because of a wide range of reasons. Hence, the use of modern methods can be a great help for the researchers. As there is no standard method for locating proper places for the establishment of the wind-catchers in the country, a pattern was prepared for the optimum locating of the wind-catchers. The results show that multi-criteria decision-making systems particularly with the help of hierarchical analysis process, GIS, and Overlaying of the information layers provide the opportunity to find proper locations. The results show that western parts of the province including Garmsar, Aradan, Sorkhe, and Semnan are better places for the wind-catchers. To sum up, use of the wind-catchers is possible and probable in houses and offices in this province.
The authors tend to thank the experts who helped in doing this study.
None.
None.
The current paper is extracted from a Ph.D. thesis by the authors "wind-catchers morphology in Semnan houses to provide suggestions for the modern architecture" and it is carried out on the author's own expense.
TABLES and CHARTS
Show attach fileCITIATION LINKS
[1]Ahmadi M, Teymouri P, Dinarvand F, Hoseinzadeh M, Babaei A A, Jaafarzadeh N (2014). Municipal solid waste landfill site selection using analytical hierarchy process method and geographic information system in Abadan, Iran. Iranian Journal of Health Science. 2(1):37–50. [Persian]
[2]Alesheikh A A, Soltani MJ, Nouri N, Khalilzadeh M (2008). Land assessment for flood spreading site selection using geospatial information system. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology. 5(4):455-462.
[3]Arab M, Farokhzad M (2020). Road residence location in Semnan province with approach to earth-sheltered architecture. Geographical Planning of Space Quaterly Journal. 9(32):181-198. [Persian]
[4]Bertolini, M, Braglia M, Carmignani G (2006). Application of the AHP methodology in making a proposal for a public work contract. International Journal of Project Management. 24(5):422-430.
[5]Beskese A, Demir H H, Ozcan H K, Okten H E (2015). Landfill site selection using fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS: A case study for Istanbul. Environmental Earth Sciences. 73(7): 3513–3521.
[6]Chou, Y C, Yen H Y, Dang V T, Sun C C (2019). Assessing the human resource in science and technology for Asian countries: Application of fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS. Symmetry. 11(2):251.
[7]Fatemi Sh, Taki D (2015). The role of architecture in optimizing energy consumption in buildings. the 3rd National Conference on Climate, Building and Optimizing Energy Consumption with a Sustainable Development Approach. [Persian]
[8]Healey M, Ilbery B (1990). Location and change: Perspective on economic geography. New York: Oxford University Press.
[9]Hekmatnia H, Ansari Zh (2012). Planning of housing in Meybod with sustainable development approach. Human Geography Research Quaterly. 44(79):191-207. [Persian]
[10]Heydari N, Doostan R, Habibi Nokhandan M (2017). Site selection of urban meteorological stations in Mashhad. Journal of Climate Research. 27(27):59-75. [Persian]
[11]Kamyabi S, Seyedalipoor S K, Hasanabadi M (2013). Site selection of the shelter in the city of Semnan with the use of the GIS analytical tool and the process of "analysis" of the HAHP series, with the approach of "4-6 city management", 49, number 1, disciplinary geography. 1(3):49-64.
[12]Kamyabi S, Seyedalipoor S K, Hasanabadi M (2013). Site selection of the shelter in the city of Semnan with the use of the GIS analytical tool and the process of "analysis" of the HAHP series, with the approach of "4-6 city management", 49, number 1, disciplinary geography. 1(3):49-64.
[13]Khajoo M, Tayebi Sani S M, Fahiminejad A, Morsal B (2019). Evaluating and Analyzing the Spatial Justice in the Distribution of Sports Applications and Services in Garmsar County. Geographical Researches. 34(4):551-558. [Persian]
[14]Khorsandi H, Faramarzi A, Aghapour A A, Jafari S J (2019). Landfill site selection via integrating multi-criteria decision techniques with geographic information systems: A case study in Naqadeh, Iran. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 730.
[15]Mahdavinejad M J, Javanroodi K (2012). Comparative Evaluation of Airflow in Two kinds of Yazdi and Kermani Wind-Towers. Journal of Honar-Haye-Ziba. 3(4):69-80. [Persian]
[16]Mahmoodi Zarandi M (2016). An analysis on the orientation, Position and Dimensions of Wind-catchers in Vernacular Houses of Yazd. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 35(153): 35-46. [Persian]
[17]Mohammadi Sangli Kh, Gharashi S (2016). Sustainable urban development; global approach with local solutions (case study: review of sustainability criteria in traditional architecture of Yazd city). Art and Architecture studies. 4 & 5(11 & 12):87-99. [Persian]
[18]Moharamnejad N, Laghai H A, Arjmandi R, Alesheikh A A, Bahmanpour H (2013). Ecological capability evaluation of outdoor recreation by integrating geographic information system (GIS) and index overlaying (IO). Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering. 38:121–134.
[19]Mokhtari M, Hosseini F, Babaee A A, Mirhoseini S A (2015). Application of AHP and TOPSIS models for site selection of municipal solid waste landfill (case study: Lali City). The Journal of Toloo-e-Behdasht. 14(4):143–153. [Persian]
[20]Morahemi Sh, Yari Broojeni N, Saadvandi M (2017). Typology of loft badgirs’ (wind towers) Based on façade ornaments. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 36(159):19-34. [Persian]
[21]Vaidya O, Kumar S (2006). Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applications. European Journal of Operational Research. 169(1):1-29.
[22]Poorahmadi M, Ayatalahi M H (2011). Refunctioning solutions for different wind catchers of Yazd based on their related summer side spaces. Journal of Architecture Hot and dry climate. 1(1):7-18. [Persian]
[23]Rathore S, Ahmad S A, Shirazi S A (2016). Use of the suitability model to identify landfill sites in Lahore-Pakistan. Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences. 12:103–108.
[24]Roohi S (2014). The use of wind energy in wind-catcherss in order to reduce the cooling load of the building. Proceedings of the 2end International Congress of Structural, Architectural and Urban Development. [Persain]
[25]SCI. [Internet] Statistical center of Iran. [Published 2019, 15 August; Cited 2019, 27 May]. Available from:
[26]Şener Ş, Sener E, Karaguzel R (2011). Solid waste disposal site selection with GIS and AHP methodology: a case study in Senirkent–Uluborlu (Isparta) Basin, Turkey. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 173(1-4):533–554.
[27]Shafei Sabet N, Hosseini Hasel S, Rahbari M (2019). Assessment of rural management, empowerment of local stakeholders and physical developments of rural settlements (Case Study: Semnan Province). Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 38(165):113-128. [persia]
[28]Shi Y, Liu X (2019). Research on the literature of green building based on the web of science: A scientometric analysis in cite space (2002–2018). Sustainability. 11(13):3716.
[29]Valipoor M, Bahrami M, Rahimabadi A, Karimi O (2014). Location of Boroujerd gas station using geographic information system (GIS). Journal of Zagros Perspective. 6(20):161-179. [Persian]
[30]Valian T, Mofidi Shemirani S M, Mahmoodi M (2020). Sustainable Development Patterns in the Architecture of Semnan Wind-Catchers. Georaphical Research Journal. 35 (2). 129-140. [Persian].
[31]Valizadeh R (2007). Location of high school educational centers using geographic information system (case study of Tabriz city). Geographical Sciences. 10:59-87.
[32]Zandieh M, Parvardinejad S (2010). Sustainable development and its concepts in Iranian residential architecture. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 29(130):2-21. [Persian]
[33]Ziabakhsh N, Sadat Zad G, Davoodi A (2011). Comparative study of sustainability in residential and indigenous architecture of hot and dry climate based on wind-catcherss and materials (Case study: Nain and Taft houses). Proceedings of National Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Urban Planning and Energy Management. [Persian]
[34]Ziari Y, Khodadadi R (2013). Investigating and locating postal service centers using AHP method in GIS environment (Case study: Semnan city). Environmental Management Journal. 6(20):177-193
[2]Alesheikh A A, Soltani MJ, Nouri N, Khalilzadeh M (2008). Land assessment for flood spreading site selection using geospatial information system. International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology. 5(4):455-462.
[3]Arab M, Farokhzad M (2020). Road residence location in Semnan province with approach to earth-sheltered architecture. Geographical Planning of Space Quaterly Journal. 9(32):181-198. [Persian]
[4]Bertolini, M, Braglia M, Carmignani G (2006). Application of the AHP methodology in making a proposal for a public work contract. International Journal of Project Management. 24(5):422-430.
[5]Beskese A, Demir H H, Ozcan H K, Okten H E (2015). Landfill site selection using fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS: A case study for Istanbul. Environmental Earth Sciences. 73(7): 3513–3521.
[6]Chou, Y C, Yen H Y, Dang V T, Sun C C (2019). Assessing the human resource in science and technology for Asian countries: Application of fuzzy AHP and fuzzy TOPSIS. Symmetry. 11(2):251.
[7]Fatemi Sh, Taki D (2015). The role of architecture in optimizing energy consumption in buildings. the 3rd National Conference on Climate, Building and Optimizing Energy Consumption with a Sustainable Development Approach. [Persian]
[8]Healey M, Ilbery B (1990). Location and change: Perspective on economic geography. New York: Oxford University Press.
[9]Hekmatnia H, Ansari Zh (2012). Planning of housing in Meybod with sustainable development approach. Human Geography Research Quaterly. 44(79):191-207. [Persian]
[10]Heydari N, Doostan R, Habibi Nokhandan M (2017). Site selection of urban meteorological stations in Mashhad. Journal of Climate Research. 27(27):59-75. [Persian]
[11]Kamyabi S, Seyedalipoor S K, Hasanabadi M (2013). Site selection of the shelter in the city of Semnan with the use of the GIS analytical tool and the process of "analysis" of the HAHP series, with the approach of "4-6 city management", 49, number 1, disciplinary geography. 1(3):49-64.
[12]Kamyabi S, Seyedalipoor S K, Hasanabadi M (2013). Site selection of the shelter in the city of Semnan with the use of the GIS analytical tool and the process of "analysis" of the HAHP series, with the approach of "4-6 city management", 49, number 1, disciplinary geography. 1(3):49-64.
[13]Khajoo M, Tayebi Sani S M, Fahiminejad A, Morsal B (2019). Evaluating and Analyzing the Spatial Justice in the Distribution of Sports Applications and Services in Garmsar County. Geographical Researches. 34(4):551-558. [Persian]
[14]Khorsandi H, Faramarzi A, Aghapour A A, Jafari S J (2019). Landfill site selection via integrating multi-criteria decision techniques with geographic information systems: A case study in Naqadeh, Iran. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 730.
[15]Mahdavinejad M J, Javanroodi K (2012). Comparative Evaluation of Airflow in Two kinds of Yazdi and Kermani Wind-Towers. Journal of Honar-Haye-Ziba. 3(4):69-80. [Persian]
[16]Mahmoodi Zarandi M (2016). An analysis on the orientation, Position and Dimensions of Wind-catchers in Vernacular Houses of Yazd. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 35(153): 35-46. [Persian]
[17]Mohammadi Sangli Kh, Gharashi S (2016). Sustainable urban development; global approach with local solutions (case study: review of sustainability criteria in traditional architecture of Yazd city). Art and Architecture studies. 4 & 5(11 & 12):87-99. [Persian]
[18]Moharamnejad N, Laghai H A, Arjmandi R, Alesheikh A A, Bahmanpour H (2013). Ecological capability evaluation of outdoor recreation by integrating geographic information system (GIS) and index overlaying (IO). Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering. 38:121–134.
[19]Mokhtari M, Hosseini F, Babaee A A, Mirhoseini S A (2015). Application of AHP and TOPSIS models for site selection of municipal solid waste landfill (case study: Lali City). The Journal of Toloo-e-Behdasht. 14(4):143–153. [Persian]
[20]Morahemi Sh, Yari Broojeni N, Saadvandi M (2017). Typology of loft badgirs’ (wind towers) Based on façade ornaments. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 36(159):19-34. [Persian]
[21]Vaidya O, Kumar S (2006). Analytic hierarchy process: An overview of applications. European Journal of Operational Research. 169(1):1-29.
[22]Poorahmadi M, Ayatalahi M H (2011). Refunctioning solutions for different wind catchers of Yazd based on their related summer side spaces. Journal of Architecture Hot and dry climate. 1(1):7-18. [Persian]
[23]Rathore S, Ahmad S A, Shirazi S A (2016). Use of the suitability model to identify landfill sites in Lahore-Pakistan. Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences. 12:103–108.
[24]Roohi S (2014). The use of wind energy in wind-catcherss in order to reduce the cooling load of the building. Proceedings of the 2end International Congress of Structural, Architectural and Urban Development. [Persain]
[25]SCI. [Internet] Statistical center of Iran. [Published 2019, 15 August; Cited 2019, 27 May]. Available from:
[26]Şener Ş, Sener E, Karaguzel R (2011). Solid waste disposal site selection with GIS and AHP methodology: a case study in Senirkent–Uluborlu (Isparta) Basin, Turkey. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 173(1-4):533–554.
[27]Shafei Sabet N, Hosseini Hasel S, Rahbari M (2019). Assessment of rural management, empowerment of local stakeholders and physical developments of rural settlements (Case Study: Semnan Province). Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 38(165):113-128. [persia]
[28]Shi Y, Liu X (2019). Research on the literature of green building based on the web of science: A scientometric analysis in cite space (2002–2018). Sustainability. 11(13):3716.
[29]Valipoor M, Bahrami M, Rahimabadi A, Karimi O (2014). Location of Boroujerd gas station using geographic information system (GIS). Journal of Zagros Perspective. 6(20):161-179. [Persian]
[30]Valian T, Mofidi Shemirani S M, Mahmoodi M (2020). Sustainable Development Patterns in the Architecture of Semnan Wind-Catchers. Georaphical Research Journal. 35 (2). 129-140. [Persian].
[31]Valizadeh R (2007). Location of high school educational centers using geographic information system (case study of Tabriz city). Geographical Sciences. 10:59-87.
[32]Zandieh M, Parvardinejad S (2010). Sustainable development and its concepts in Iranian residential architecture. Journal of Housing and Rural Environment. 29(130):2-21. [Persian]
[33]Ziabakhsh N, Sadat Zad G, Davoodi A (2011). Comparative study of sustainability in residential and indigenous architecture of hot and dry climate based on wind-catcherss and materials (Case study: Nain and Taft houses). Proceedings of National Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, Urban Planning and Energy Management. [Persian]
[34]Ziari Y, Khodadadi R (2013). Investigating and locating postal service centers using AHP method in GIS environment (Case study: Semnan city). Environmental Management Journal. 6(20):177-193